• Home
  • About
    • Privacy Policy
    • Write for Australian Women Online
  • Advertise With Us
  • Horoscopes
  • Style
  • Shoe Boutique
  • eFashion
  • Weight Watchers Australia

Australian Women Online

Business, career, health and lifestyle content for women

  • Home
  • BLOG
  • BOOKS
  • BUSINESS
  • CAREER
  • COOKING
  • HEALTH
  • LIFESTYLE
    • Automotive
    • Beauty
    • Fashion
    • Pets
    • Relationships
    • Your Home
    • Your Money
  • TECHNOLOGY
  • TRAVEL
    • Discount Holidays
You are here: Home / NEWS & POLITICS / Domestic Violence / The Battle between Kesha and her Producer from a Legal Perspective

The Battle between Kesha and her Producer from a Legal Perspective

22 March 2016 by Karen Cho @Owen Hodge Lawyers

Share this:

  • Tweet
  • Email
  • More
  • Share on Tumblr
  • Print
  • WhatsApp

Photo source: Mirror UK

Photo source: Mirror UK

The legal battle between U.S. singer/songwriter Kesha and her long-time producer Dr Luke (pictured) is full of sordid stuff – allegations of rape, emotional blackmail and financial abuse. #FreeKesha lit up Twitter when a New York judge recently refused to release her from her recording contracts.
But to understand the legal perspective, it is important to remember that this is not a criminal trial. It is a contract case. Courts generally try to preserve the enforceability of agreements that people make between themselves, however ill-advised. They will not nanny unless something is terribly wrong.

Is something terribly wrong? That is a hard question that requires balancing legal theory and economic reality. The results are not always satisfying.

The Facts

In 2005 Kesha, then barely 18, entered into a series of agreements with Kasz Money, Inc., Kemosabe Records, LLC , Prescription Songs, LLC and ultimately Sony Music to make records.

  • In a lawsuit filed in California in 2014, she alleges that she was the victim of gross abuse and asked the court to:
    void the contracts;
  • permit her to make agreements with other recording companies free of interference; and
  • award money damages.

That case has not yet gone to trial. Although some of the accusations against Dr Luke might be prosecuted as crimes under California law, she has not filed a criminal complaint. Nor did she seek the assistance of law enforcement at the time the abuse reportedly occurred. No matter how disturbing her allegations, in the eyes of the law it’s just a contract case.

When Can a Contract be Set Aside?

Courts may nullify or modify a contract because of circumstances that exist at the time the agreement is made or because of things that happen later.

If a party’s consent to the terms of an agreement is not genuine because it was induced by fraud, duress or undue influence, courts may throw it out.

If someone lacks the mental capacity to understand the terms of an agreement (as might be the case with dementia, psychosis or intellectual disability) when the contract is made, courts may similarly declare it void.

Minors may ask that a contract be voided. It is important to note that, although very young, Kesha was not legally a minor at the time she made these agreements.

Contracts to do something illegal or something that becomes illegal or impossible after the agreement is made cannot be enforced. In rare circumstances, courts will also consider whether performance has become commercially impracticable.

Whether any of the allegations made by Kesha fit within these categories is difficult to say because the evidence has yet to be heard by a jury, as she requested. This was likely why the New York court was reluctant to release her from her contract prior to trial.

Photo source: Entertainment Weekly

Photo source: Entertainment Weekly

Does Kesha Have to Work for an Abuser?

This is why people care. Although the legal answer is “no,” the practical situation is muddier.

Slavery has been illegal in the United States for 150 years. The Thirteenth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution protects Kesha from being legally compelled to make more albums. If she refuses, however, she may be liable for breach of contract.

Would it kill her career? If she continues to record but with a different producer, as Sony has offered, she fears that her albums will not be promoted. If she refuses, other record labels may be reluctant to pick her up fearing legal retribution.

Is she already untouchable for exercising her legal rights? That’s the ugly question.

Twitter says that Kesha is not alone. If you have questions about your contractual obligations or the circumstances under which a contract may be nullified, please contact an attorney at Owen Hodge Lawyers at 1800 780 770.

Owen Hodge SolicitorsAbout the Author
Karen Cho, Lawyer, Owen Hodge Lawyers
With nearly a decade of experience in the legal profession, Karen’s main areas of interest include conveyancing, criminal law, debt recovery, civil litigation, commercial transactions and wills and probate matters. For every client Karen strives to reach positive outcomes and she does this by offering attentive, time-effective and friendly service.

You May Also Like:

Filed Under: Domestic Violence, NEWS & POLITICS, Uncategorized

Ads by Google
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter

New Content

  • Customer Onboarding Guide – Fraud Detection and Prevention
  • How to Start a Business: Main Points to Consider
  • Pieces of Advice on How to Rebuild Your Credit Score by Taking a Personal Loan
  • What you Should Pay Attention to when Crypto Trading
  • 5 Easy Side Hustles That You Can Start Today
  • How to Choose Women’s Winter Slippers in 2022
  • How can I edit my statement of purpose?
  • The best marketing tool for your brand? History
  • Gold Bullion: Investing in Gold for Beginners
  • Is Comprehensive Car Insurance a Good Investment?

Popular Content

  • Sexy and Stylish Short Hairstyles for Women Over 60
  • Moore Weekly Stars
  • The 10 Best Side Dishes For Ribs
  • Papua New Guinean TV drama 'It Takes A Village' will make Australian debut on International Women's Day
  • Top 9 Cars for Women in Australia
  • Jamie Oliver Christmas Recipes using Aussie meat and produce
  • Aussie Mums open male escort agency catering exclusively to women
  • The 4 Best Cooking Oils for Your BBQ
  • Manning Cartell Ciao Bella Mini Dress
  • Youthful and Trendy Short Hairstyles For Women Over 50

Australian Women Online © Copyright 2007 - 2022 Deborah Robinson ABN 38 119 171 979 · All Rights Reserved