• Home
  • About
    • Privacy Policy
    • Write for Australian Women Online
  • Advertise With Us
  • Horoscopes
  • Style
  • Shoe Boutique
  • eFashion
  • Weight Watchers Australia

Australian Women Online

Business, career, health and lifestyle content for women

  • Home
  • BLOG
  • BOOKS
  • BUSINESS
  • CAREER
  • COOKING
  • HEALTH
  • LIFESTYLE
    • Automotive
    • Beauty
    • Fashion
    • Pets
    • Relationships
    • Your Home
    • Your Money
  • TECHNOLOGY
  • TRAVEL
    • Discount Holidays
You are here: Home / LIFESTYLE / Change of Approach to Artistic Merit in Child Pornography Laws

Change of Approach to Artistic Merit in Child Pornography Laws

17 January 2010 by Danielle Hutchinson

Share this:

  • Tweet
  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
  • More
  • Share on Tumblr
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window) Reddit
  • Click to print (Opens in new window) Print
  • Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) WhatsApp

The Arts Law Centre of Australia’s Executive Director, Robyn Ayres says “the likely impact of the proposed changes to the NSW child pornography laws on artists is unclear at this stage”.

“On the one hand the CPWP recommends that the defence of artistic merit be removed from the NSW Crimes Act. However when a court is considering the questions of whether material is child pornography and if it is offensive the court must consider the literary, artistic or educational merit (if any) of the material,” she said.

“The court must also consider standards of decency and morality as well as the general character of the material including if it is of a medical, legal or scientific character. If the court still concludes that the material is child pornography after taking these matters into consideration and hearing expert evidence about such matters, then there is no artistic merit defence”.

Whilst the changes would harmonise NSW with the way the Commonwealth and territories approach child pornography cases, it will mean NSW is out of sync with Victoria, Tasmania, WA and Queensland where the criminal laws provide an artistic merit defence.

Ayres says “A potential positive impact is that the prosecuting authorities will need to turn their mind immediately to the question of whether the work was for a genuine artistic purpose before charging anyone with a child pornography offence. With proper training, hopefully this will overcome heavy handed behaviour by the police in seizing artworks which end up being given a G or PG rating, as happened with Bill Henson’s work.”

Robyn Ayres also said “Subsequent to the Bill Henson debate, the Australia Council developed protocols aimed at helping artists and arts organisations understand the law when working with children. These protocols have effectively added a layer of complexity which is unnecessary and reach beyond the requirements of the law.”

“The protocols appear to have had the greatest impact on arts organisations and have caused unfortunate results. For example, an arts organisation was not able to publish a very innocent photo of a small child with a portion of her chest showing without having the image classified. Classification is a costly and time consuming process which is prohibitive and many artists or arts organisations will simply decide to withdraw the work rather than classify it because of this. These requirements are adding both administrative and financial burdens to arts organisations and galleries as well as causing delays to the publication or exhibition of works and are in addition to the normal legal requirements”.

The CPWP Report also recommends the implementation of uniform scale of seriousness in categorising various types of child pornography.

“Not only will this provide guidance to the courts but also to the police as to what sort of material falls within the definition of child pornography and what doesn’t. Hopefully this will reduce the likelihood of situations arising where innocent material is treated as child pornography”.

Source: Arts Law Centre of Australia

You May Also Like:

Filed Under: LIFESTYLE, Uncategorized

Ads by Google
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter

New Content

  • Women in Wagering: How the Industry is Finally Tapping Female Players
  • Demolition Safety: 10 Essential Safety Tips and Guidelines
  • The Best E-Scooters in Australia: Features to Look For in 2025
  • Tips for Lingerie Shopping
  • The Checklist: How to Maintain a Commercial Vehicle
  • Safe and Fast: Payment Methods Used by Aussie Online Casino Players
  • Shade Without the Struggle: The Pergola That Makes Sense
  • Creating a Supportive Work Environment with Mental Health and Wellbeing Services
  • 10 Questions You Should Ask to Find the Right Pop-up Camper for You
  • Kangaroo Island Volunteers Pursue Ambitious Dream to Recreate Historic 19th Century Sailing Ship

Popular Content

  • Moore Weekly Stars
  • Women Who Have Become Gambling Legends
  • The Best E-Scooters in Australia: Features to Look For in 2025
  • Sexy and Stylish Short Hairstyles for Women Over 60
  • CHARLES & KEITH Large Geometric Handbag
  • Senso Cassie Sandals
  • Weight Watchers Australia coupons, flash sales and discounts on joining fees & plans
  • These are Australia's biggest female esports players
  • Write for Australian Women Online
  • Cookbook: CWA Classics by the Country Women’s Associations of Australia

Australian Women Online © Copyright 2007 - 2025 Deborah Robinson ABN 38 119 171 979 · All Rights Reserved