• Home
  • About
    • Privacy Policy
    • Write for Australian Women Online
  • Advertise With Us
  • Horoscopes
  • Style
  • Shoe Boutique
  • eFashion
  • Weight Watchers Australia

Australian Women Online

Business, career, health and lifestyle content for women

  • Home
  • BLOG
  • BOOKS
  • BUSINESS
  • CAREER
  • COOKING
  • HEALTH
  • LIFESTYLE
    • Automotive
    • Beauty
    • Fashion
    • Pets
    • Relationships
    • Your Home
    • Your Money
  • TECHNOLOGY
  • TRAVEL
    • Discount Holidays
You are here: Home / NEWS & POLITICS / Women in Politics / What are Senator Hanson-Young’s legal rights in response to Senator Leyonhjelm’s “slut shaming”?

What are Senator Hanson-Young’s legal rights in response to Senator Leyonhjelm’s “slut shaming”?

22 August 2018 by Rolf Howard

Share this:

  • Tweet
  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
  • More
  • Share on Tumblr
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window) Reddit
  • Click to print (Opens in new window) Print
  • Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) WhatsApp

What are Senator Hanson-Young’s legal rights in response to Senator Leyonhjelm’s “slut shaming”?

Pictured: Sarah Hanson Young

By Rolf Howard, Managing Partner, Owen Hodge Lawyers

It all began on 28 June, during a parliamentary debate about pepper sprays and violence against women. Senator David Leyonhjelm shouted at Senator Sarah Hanson-Young to “stop shagging men.”

She demanded an apology. He replied with an unprintable suggestion, and things promptly got worse. Senator Leyonhjelm repeated his comments and other accusations to various media outlets, including Sky News, the ABC’s 7.30 program, Channel Ten’s The Project and Melbourne radio station 3AW. Senator Hanson-Young, he implied, was a “hypocrite” for “hating men” and a “slut, shagging men indiscriminately.” Hanson-Young has declared that she is suing Senator Leyonhjelm for defamation.

“Slut shaming” is coarse; it’s crude; it’s obnoxious – and it’s all too common. But is it defamation? The question is more challenging than you might think.

What is defamation?

Under NSW’s Defamation Act 2005, “defamation” is:
1. an untrue statement of fact (spoken, written or communicated by gestures or symbols);
2. about an identifiable person or small group of people;
3. communicated to a third party;
4. which injures the personal or business reputation of the person claiming to be defamed

That definition opens up a lot of exceptions – true statements, statements of honest opinion, statements that no one else heard or read and statements that, although abusive, do no harm to someone’s reputation. Can someone whose reputation is already in tatters be defamed? What about a public figure? Allegations of promiscuity usually clear the bar of being harmful to someone’s reputation, but these standards are flexible, changeable and highly fact-specific.

There are also other exceptions for specific situations in which freedom of expression is thought to be especially important. These include statements made in court and, more importantly, debates on the floor of Parliament. So, the question about whether Senator Leyonhjelm’s comments were defamatory is limited to his media interviews.

What are Sarah Hanson-Young’s legal rights?

Senator Hanson-Young has already taken the first step, which is to issue a “concerns notice,” which is basically a demand for an apology. The period of time during which Senator Leyonhjelm could have made amends is now past, so the next step is a lawsuit.

She may seek money damages for the damage done to her reputation. She has announced that she intends to donate any recovery to charities, including Plan International Australia, which tackles harassment and abuse of women in Australia and overseas.

But will she win, and if so, how much?

Senator Hanson-Young’s claim certainly seems to check many of the necessary boxes, but Senator Leyonhjelm has mounted a defense, characterising his comments as “abusive,” but not actually harmful to reputation. That may be a major hurdle for someone who is a well-known public figure, like Senator Hanson-Young, because many people already have firmly held convictions.

The biggest problem for ordinary people who feel that they have been defamed is that a monetary award may not be an effective way to deal with harm to reputation. The damage is done when the lie is spread, and a court battle may actually make things worse by bringing greater attention to it.

Further, damage, especially to personal reputation, can be difficult to measure monetarily. A financial recovery, while a moral victory, may not be particularly large. For both of these reasons, an apology and retraction may be more valuable.

About Rolf Howard
Rolf is Managing Partner of Owen Hodge Lawyers. He has been in the legal practice since 1986 and a partner of Owen Hodge Lawyers since 1992. Rolf focuses on assisting clients to proactively manage legal responsibilities and opportunities to achieve competitive advantage. Rolf concentrates on business planning and formation, directors’ duties, corporate governance, fund raising and business succession. His major interest is to assist business owners and their financial advisers plan and implement strategies to build and exit from successful businesses.

You May Also Like:

Filed Under: Women in Politics

Ads by Google
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter

New Content

  • How to Become a Trusted Home Care Provider in Australia (and Simplify Your Operations in 2025)
  • Empowering Women Through Fashion Entrepreneurship: How Custom Caps Become Catalysts for Change
  • How to Ladder Your Term Deposits for Maximum Flexibility & Returns
  • Women in Wagering: How the Industry is Finally Tapping Female Players
  • Demolition Safety: 10 Essential Safety Tips and Guidelines
  • The Best E-Scooters in Australia: Features to Look For in 2025
  • Tips for Lingerie Shopping
  • The Checklist: How to Maintain a Commercial Vehicle
  • Safe and Fast: Payment Methods Used by Aussie Online Casino Players
  • Shade Without the Struggle: The Pergola That Makes Sense

Popular Content

  • How to Become a Trusted Home Care Provider in Australia (and Simplify Your Operations in 2025)
  • Moore Weekly Stars
  • Cathy Freeman blogs about her experiences as a mum
  • Write for Australian Women Online
  • Sass & Bide Shot Of Love Asymmetric Midi Dress Black
  • Rip Curl Daybreak Digital Watch Rose Gold
  • Book Review: Unnatural Habits by Kerry Greenwood
  • About
  • Privacy Policy
  • Alice McCall Floral Salvatore Pants

Australian Women Online © Copyright 2007 - 2025 Deborah Robinson ABN 38 119 171 979 · All Rights Reserved